Comprehensive Truck Size and Weight Limits Study - Compliance Comparative Analysis Technical Report
Appendix D: Identification of Affected Statutes and Regulations
This appendix identifies statutes and regulations that would be impacted by the widespread operation of alternative truck configurations on all roads and highways on which Surface Transportation Assistance Act (STAA) vehicles can now operate. The review focuses on relevant language contained in:
- US Code Title 23: Highways
- US Code Title 49: Transportation
- Code of Federal Regulations, Title 23, Part 658 and Title 49 Parts 390-399
U.S. Code Title 23, Section 127 on Vehicle Weight Limitations on the Interstate System and its corresponding regulations contained in the Code of Federal Regulations Title 23, Part 658, are primarily administered by Federal Highway Administration. U.S. Code Title 49, Chapter 311 on Commercial Motor Vehicle Safety, Sections 31111-31115 on length and width limitations are administered by FHWA, but enforced, as safety requirements, through Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) regulations. The length and width limitations from Title 49 are contained in the same regulations administered by FHWA. These are in the Code of Federal Regulations Title 23, Part 658.
U.S. Code Title 23, Section 127 - Vehicles Weight Limitations-Interstate System
The United States statutes (U.S. Code) covering vehicle weight limitations on the Interstate System for commercial vehicles are included in Title 23 of the U.S. Code, Section 127. Current statutory language from the relevant passages of this section are included in their entirety in the chart that follows along with the comments associated with sections impacted by a change in Federal truck size and weight limits. Additionally, to aid in the referencing of sections that would be impacted by a change in current Federal truck size and weight limits, the specific language impacted is underlined in the current statutory language.
Current Statutory Language | Impacts |
---|---|
(a) In General.- (1) The Secretary shall withhold 50 percent of the apportionment of a State under section 104 (b)(1) in any fiscal year in which the State does not permit the use of The Dwight D. Eisenhower System of Interstate and Defense Highways within its boundaries by vehicles with a weight of twenty thousand pounds carried on any one axle, including enforcement tolerances, or with a tandem axle weight of thirty-four thousand pounds, including enforcement tolerances, or a gross weight of at least eighty thousand pounds for vehicle combinations of five axles or more. |
The reference to gross vehicle weight would be impacted if certain configurations included in the study were adopted. |
(2) However, the maximum gross weight to be allowed by any State for vehicles using The Dwight D. Eisenhower System of Interstate and Defense Highways shall be twenty thousand pounds carried on one axle, including enforcement tolerances, and a tandem axle weight of thirty-four thousand pounds, including enforcement tolerances and with an overall maximum gross weight, including enforcement tolerances, on a group of two or more consecutive axles produced by application of the following formula:
where W equals overall gross weight on any group of two or more consecutive axles to the nearest five hundred pounds, L equals distance in feet between the extreme of any group of two or more consecutive axles, and N equals number of axles in group under consideration, except that two consecutive sets of tandem axles may carry a gross load of thirty-four thousand pounds each providing the overall distance between the first and last axles of such consecutive sets of tandem axles (1) is thirty-six feet or more, or (2) in the case of a motor vehicle hauling any tank trailer, dump trailer, or ocean transport container before September 1, 1989, is 30 feet or more: Provided, That such overall gross weight may not exceed eighty thousand pounds, including all enforcement tolerances, except for vehicles using Interstate Route 29 between Sioux City, Iowa, and the border between Iowa and South Dakota or vehicles using Interstate Route 129 between Sioux City, Iowa, and the border between Iowa and Nebraska, and except for those vehicles and loads which cannot be easily dismantled or divided and which have been issued special permits in accordance with applicable State laws, or the corresponding maximum weights permitted for vehicles using the public highways of such State under laws or regulations established by appropriate State authority in effect on July 1, 1956, except in the case of the overall gross weight of any group of two or more consecutive axles on any vehicle (other than a vehicle comprised of a motor vehicle hauling any tank trailer, dump trailer, or ocean transport container on or after September 1, 1989), on the date of enactment of the Federal-Aid Highway Amendments of 1974, whichever is the greater. |
Paragraph (2) refers to the Bridge Formula B (BFB), which governs weights on the Interstate System. It would be potentially impacted if the six-axle, 97,000-pound truck or five-axle, 88,000=pound truck are adopted; neither comply with the Federal bridge formula as written in this section. The truck configurations shown in Table 2 that would not comply with bridge formula calculated limits are the 88,000-pound five-axle, the 97,000-pound six-axle, and the 129,000-pound nin-axle configurations. For those configurations to comply with the bridge formula, allowances for non-compliance with the formula or modifications to the formula would be needed. Also, paragraph (2) would be impacted by any new axle or gross vehicle weights limits enacted. |
(d) Longer Combination Vehicles.- (A) General continuation rule.- A longer combination vehicle may continue to operate only if the longer combination vehicle configuration type was authorized by State officials pursuant to State statute or regulation conforming to this section and in actual lawful operation on a regular or periodic basis (including seasonal operations) on or before June 1, 1991, or pursuant to section 335 of the Department of Transportation and Related Agencies Appropriations Act, 1991 (104 Stat. 2186). |
If triple trailer combinations are allowed for use on Interstate System and the National Highway System and the National Network there would need to be an amendment to this section reflecting the new date of enactment of the allowance referenced. |
(B) Applicability of State laws and regulations.- All such operations shall continue to be subject to, at the minimum, all State statutes, regulations, limitations and conditions, including, but not limited to, routing-specific and configuration-specific designations and all other restrictions, in force on June 1, 1991; except that subject to such regulations as may be issued by the Secretary pursuant to paragraph (5) of this subsection, the State may make minor adjustments of a temporary and emergency nature to route designations and vehicle operating restrictions in effect on June 1, 1991, for specific safety purposes and road construction. |
This section would be impacted through adoption of the triple trailer combinations for broader mobility privileges. |
(C) Wyoming.- In addition to those vehicles allowed under subparagraph (A), the State of Wyoming may allow the operation of additional vehicle configurations not in actual operation on June 1, 1991, but authorized by State law not later than November 3, 1992, if such vehicle configurations comply with the single axle, tandem axle, and bridge formula limits set forth in subsection (a) and do not exceed 117,000 pounds gross vehicle weight. |
This paragraph for Wyoming would be impacted and need to be amended if triple trailer combinations with 28 or 28.5-foot trailers and 9 or 10 axles weighing 129,000 pounds are allowed. |
(D) Ohio.- In addition to vehicles which the State of Ohio may continue to allow to be operated under subparagraph (A), such State may allow longer combination vehicles with 3 cargo carrying units of 281/2 feet each (not including the truck tractor) not in actual operation on June 1, 1991, to be operated within its boundaries on the 1-mile segment of State of Ohio Route 7 which begins at and is south of exit 16 of the Ohio Turnpike. |
This paragraph would be impacted and may need to be changed since Ohio is now allowed 115,000 pounds on triple trailer combinations and could need to allow 129,000 pounds to accommodate scenario vehicles. |
(E) Alaska.- In addition to vehicles which the State of Alaska may continue to allow to be operated under subparagraph (A), such State may allow the operation of longer combination vehicles which were not in actual operation on June 1, 1991, but which were in actual operation prior to July 5, 1991. |
This section would be impacted in light of the July 5th date, if the triple trailer combination is adopted. Alaska is exempt from Interstate System weight laws. |
(F) Iowa - In addition to vehicles that the State of Iowa may continue to allow to be operated under subparagraph (A), the State may allow longer combination vehicles that were not in actual operation on June 1, 1991, to be operated on Interstate Route 29 between Sioux City, Iowa, and the border between Iowa and South Dakota or Interstate Route 129 between Sioux City, Iowa, and the border between Iowa and Nebraska. |
This section would be impacted. There would not need to be any adjustment to this statutory language, but there would need to be adjustments if triple trailer combinations are adopted by Congress, since lengths and widths are restricted below those configurations. |
(2) Additional State restrictions.- (A) In general. - Nothing in this subsection shall prevent any State from further restricting in any manner or prohibiting the operation of longer combination vehicles otherwise authorized under this subsection; except that such restrictions or prohibitions shall be consistent with the requirements of sections 31111-31114 of title 49. |
If the restriction is lifted for triple trailer combinations then this paragraph would be impacted and need to be modified. |
(B) Minor adjustments. - Any State further restricting or prohibiting the operations of longer combination vehicles or making minor adjustments of a temporary and emergency nature as may be allowed pursuant to regulations issued by the Secretary pursuant to paragraph (5) of this subsection, shall, within 30 days, advise the Secretary of such action, and the Secretary shall publish a notice of such action in the Federal Register. |
This paragraph may not need to be modified. It appears to fit within the context of lifting some LCV restrictions but not lifting others. |
(3) Publication of list.- (A) Submission to secretary.- Within 60 days of the date of the enactment of this subsection, each State (i) shall submit to the Secretary for publication in the Federal Register a complete list of (I) all operations of longer combination vehicles being conducted as of June 1, 1991, pursuant to State statutes and regulations; (II) all limitations and conditions, including, but not limited to, routing-specific and configuration-specific designations and all other restrictions, governing the operation of longer combination vehicles otherwise prohibited under this subsection; and (III) such statutes, regulations, limitations, and conditions; and (ii) shall submit to the Secretary copies of such statutes, regulations, limitations, and conditions. |
This paragraph may be impacted if triple trailer combinations are adopted. Relevant modifications would be needed for any modifications made to LCV allowances and would need to reflect the new grandfather date. Also, it may need to separate the LCVs reviewed and analyzed in this Study versus those LCVs that were not studied and will continue to operate under the June 1, 1991 restriction. |
(B) Interim list. - Not later than 90 days after the date of the enactment of this subsection, the Secretary shall publish an interim list in the Federal Register, consisting of all information submitted pursuant to subparagraph (A). The Secretary shall review for accuracy all information submitted by the States pursuant to subparagraph (A) and shall solicit and consider public comment on the accuracy of all such information. |
No impact is specifically noted; the utility of this section is questionable if modifications to LCV freeze provisions are adopted. |
(C) Limitation.- No statute or regulation shall be included on the list submitted by a State or published by the Secretary merely on the grounds that it authorized, or could have authorized, by permit or otherwise, the operation of longer combination vehicles, not in actual operation on a regular or periodic basis on or before June 1, 1991. |
This paragraph would be impacted. It is relevant for any modification of LCV allowances and would need to reference the enactment as separate from the 1991 enactment. |
(D) Final list.- Except as modified pursuant to paragraph (1)(C) of this subsection, the list shall be published as final in the Federal Register not later than 180 days after the date of the enactment of this subsection. In publishing the final list, the Secretary shall make any revisions necessary to correct inaccuracies identified under subparagraph (B). After publication of the final list, longer combination vehicles may not operate on the Interstate System except as provided in the list. |
This paragraph would be relevant for any modification of LCV allowances. |
(E) Review and correction procedure. - The Secretary, on his or her own motion or upon a request by any person (including a State), shall review the list issued by the Secretary pursuant to subparagraph (D). If the Secretary determines there is cause to believe that a mistake was made in the accuracy of the final list, the Secretary shall commence a proceeding to determine whether the list published pursuant to subparagraph (D) should be corrected. If the Secretary determines that there is a mistake in the accuracy of the list the Secretary shall correct the publication under subparagraph (D) to reflect the determination of the Secretary. |
This paragraph may be relevant for any modification of LCV allowances. The new enactment date would also be referenced. |
U.S. Code Title 49, Chapter 311 - Commercial Motor Vehicle Safety, Subchapter II - Length and Width Limitations
The United States statutes (U.S. Code) covering length and width limitations for commercial vehicles are included in Title 49 of the U.S. Code, Chapter 311. More specifically, the length and width limitations are included in Subchapter II of Chapter 311. Specific sections of relevance are Sections 31111, 31112, and 31114. Current statutory language from the relevant passages of these sections are included in their entirety in the chart that follows, along with the comments associated with sections impacted by a change in Federal truck size and weight limits. Additionally, to aid in referencing sections that would be impacted by a change in current Federal truck size and weight limits, the specific language impacted is underlined in the current statutory language.
Current Statutory Language | Impacts |
---|---|
§ 31111 - Length Limitations (b) General Limitations.- (1) Except as provided in this section, a State may not prescribe or enforce a regulation of commerce that- (A) imposes a vehicle length limitation of less than 45 feet on a bus, of less than 48 feet on a semitrailer operating in a truck tractor-semitrailer combination, or of less than 28 feet on a semitrailer or trailer operating in a truck tractor-semitrailer-trailer combination, on any segment of the Dwight D. Eisenhower System of Interstate and Defense Highways (except a segment exempted under subsection (f) of this section) and those classes of qualifying Federal-aid Primary System highways designated by the Secretary of Transportation under subsection (e) of this section; (B) imposes an overall length limitation on a commercial motor vehicle operating in a truck tractor-semitrailer or truck tractor-semitrailer-trailer combination; (C) has the effect of prohibiting the use of a semitrailer or trailer of the same dimensions as those that were in actual and lawful use in that State on December 1, 1982; (D) imposes a vehicle length limitation of not less than or more than 97 feet on all driveaway saddlemount vehicle transporter combinations; (E) has the effect of prohibiting the use of an existing semitrailer or trailer, of not more than 28.5 feet in length, in a truck tractor-semitrailer-trailer combination if the semitrailer or trailer was operating lawfully on December 1, 1982, within a 65-foot overall length limit in any State; or (F) imposes a limitation of less than 46 feet on the distance from the kingpin to the center of the rear axle on trailers used exclusively or primarily in connection with motorsports competition events. (2) A length limitation prescribed or enforced by a State under paragraph (1)(A) of this subsection applies only to a semitrailer or trailer and not to a truck tractor. |
If twin 33-foot double- and triple-trailer combinations are adopted for use on the Interstate System, the dates referenced in the existing statutes would need to reflect any changes in relevant dates associated with those specific configurations considered to be allowed. In addition, the overall length limit for twin 33-foot doubles will exceed 65 feet, and therefore accommodation will need to be made for that. Additionally, (b)(1)(A) would need to be modified with 33 feet replacing 28 feet, (b)(1)(C) would need to be removed, and (b)(1)(E) would need to be removed. |
(e) Qualifying Highways. - The Secretary by regulation shall designate as qualifying Federal-aid Primary System highways those highways of the Federal-aid Primary System in existence on June 1, 1991, that can accommodate safely the applicable vehicle lengths provided in this section. |
|
§ 31112 - Property-carrying Unit Limitation (a) Definitions.- In this section- (1) "property-carrying unit" means any part of a commercial motor vehicle combination (except the truck tractor) used to carry property, including a trailer, a semitrailer, or the property-carrying section of a single unit truck. (2) the length of the property-carrying units of a commercial motor vehicle combination is the length measured from the front of the first property-carrying unit to the rear of the last property-carrying unit. (b) General Limitations.- A State may not allow by any means the operation, on any segment of the Dwight D. Eisenhower System of Interstate and Defense Highways and those classes of qualifying Federal-aid Primary System highways designated by the Secretary of Transportation under section 31111 (e) of this title, of any commercial motor vehicle combination (except a vehicle or load that cannot be dismantled easily or divided easily and that has been issued a special permit under applicable State law) with more than one property-carrying unit (not including the truck tractor) whose property-carrying units are more than- (1) the maximum combination trailer, semitrailer, or other type of length limitation allowed by law or regulation of that State before June 2, 1991; or (2) the length of the property-carrying units of those commercial motor vehicle combinations, by specific configuration, in actual, lawful operation on a regular or periodic basis (including continuing seasonal operation) in that State before June 2, 1991. |
If the twin 33-foot double- and triple-trailer combinations are permitted to operate around the country, and the States would be allowed to permit their operation, this section would not need to be changed. If Federal law stated that permits would not be needed for these types of combinations, then allowance would need to be made in this section for these configurations. |
(c) Special Rules for Wyoming, Ohio, Alaska, Iowa, and Nebraska.- In addition to the vehicles allowed under subsection (b) of this section- (1) Wyoming may allow the operation of additional vehicle configurations not in actual operation on June 1, 1991, but authorized by State law not later than November 3, 1992, if the vehicle configurations comply with the single axle, tandem axle, and bridge formula limits in section 127 (a) of title 23 and are not more than 117,000 pounds gross vehicle weight; |
This paragraph would need to be modified to reflect a new enactment date for any alternative configuration provided greater mobility privileges. A modification to the gross weight limit noted would need to be applied if triple-trailer combinations of 129,000 pounds gross vehicle weight are allowed. |
(d) Additional Limitations.- (1) A commercial motor vehicle combination whose operation in a State is not prohibited under subsections (b) and (c) of this section may continue to operate in the State on highways described in subsection (b) only if at least in compliance with all State laws, regulations, limitations, and conditions, including routing-specific and configuration-specific designations and all other restrictions in force in the State on June 1, 1991. However, subject to regulations prescribed by the Secretary under subsection (g)(2) of this section, the State may make minor adjustments of a temporary and emergency nature to route designations and vehicle operating restrictions in effect on June 1, 1991, for specific safety purposes and road construction. (2) This section does not prevent a State from further restricting in any way or prohibiting the operation of any commercial motor vehicle combination subject to this section, except that a restriction or prohibition shall be consistent with this section and sections 31113 (a) and (b) and 31114 of this title. (3) A State making a minor adjustment of a temporary and emergency nature as authorized by paragraph (1) of this subsection or further restricting or prohibiting the operation of a commercial motor vehicle combination as authorized by paragraph (2) of this subsection shall advise the Secretary not later than 30 days after the action. The Secretary shall publish a notice of the action in the Federal Register. (4) [1] Nebraska may continue to allow to be operated under paragraphs (b)(1) and (b)(2) of this section, [2] the State of Nebraska may allow longer combination vehicles that were not in actual operation on June 1, 1991 to be operated within its boundaries to transport sugar beets from the field where such sugar beets are harvested to storage, market, factory or stockpile or from stockpile to storage, market or factory. This provision shall expire on February 28, 1998. |
This section would need to be amended to reflect the date of enactment for any configuration considered in this study to be allowed greater mobility privileges. |
(e) List of State Length Limitations.- (1) Not later than February 16, 1992, each State shall submit to the Secretary for publication a complete list of State length limitations applicable to commercial motor vehicle combinations operating in the State on the highways described in subsection (b) of this section. The list shall indicate the applicable State laws and regulations associated with the length limitations. If a State does not submit the information as required, the Secretary shall complete and file the information for the State. (2) Not later than March 17, 1992, the Secretary shall publish an interim list in the Federal Register consisting of all information submitted under paragraph (1) of this subsection. The Secretary shall review for accuracy all information submitted by a State under paragraph (1) and shall solicit and consider public comment on the accuracy of the information. (3) A law or regulation may not be included on the list submitted by a State or published by the Secretary merely because it authorized, or could have authorized, by permit or otherwise, the operation of commercial motor vehicle combinations not in actual operation on a regular or periodic basis before June 2, 1991. (4) Except as revised under this paragraph or paragraph (5) of this subsection, the list shall be published as final in the Federal Register not later than June 15, 1992. In publishing the final list, the Secretary shall make any revisions necessary to correct inaccuracies identified under paragraph (2) of this subsection. After publication of the final list, commercial motor vehicle combinations prohibited under subsection (b) of this section may not operate on the Dwight D. Eisenhower System of Interstate and Defense Highways and other Federal-aid Primary System highways designated by the Secretary except as published on the list. The list may be combined by the Secretary with the list required under section 127 (d) of title 23. (5) On the Secretary's own motion or on request by any person (including a State), the Secretary shall review the list published under paragraph (4) of this subsection. If the Secretary decides there is reason to believe a mistake was made in the accuracy of the list, the Secretary shall begin a proceeding to decide whether a mistake was made. If the Secretary decides there was a mistake, the Secretary shall publish the correction. |
(e) May be removed or modified at the discretion of Congress. In either case, it will be impacted by any change in truck size and weight limits being assessed in the 2014 CTSW Study. |
§ 31114 - Access to the Interstate System (a) Prohibition on Denying Access.- A State may not enact or enforce a law denying to a commercial motor vehicle subject to this subchapter or subchapter I of this chapter reasonable access between- (1) the Dwight D. Eisenhower System of Interstate and Defense Highways (except a segment exempted under section 31111 (f) or 31113 (e) of this title) and other qualifying Federal-aid Primary System highways designated by the Secretary of Transportation; and (2) terminals, facilities for food, fuel, repairs, and rest, and points of loading and unloading for household goods carriers, motor carriers of passengers, or any truck tractor-semitrailer combination in which the semitrailer has a length of not more than 28.5 feet and that generally operates as part of a vehicle combination described in section 31111(c) of this title. (b) Exception.- This section does not prevent a State or local government from imposing reasonable restrictions, based on safety considerations, on a truck tractor-semitrailer combination in which the semitrailer has a length of not more than 28.5 feet and that generally operates as part of a vehicle combination described in section 31111(c) of this title. |
Under paragraph (2) in this section, reference is made to section 31111[c] as it relates to vehicle combinations having access to certain facilities. That section would still remain as the referenced source if it is changed to enable the legal use of the alternative configurations. If the twin 33-foot doubles are allowed STAA mobility privileges, the reference to the 28.5-foot length would be replaced with 33 feet. |
Code of Federal Regulations Title 23 Part 658 - Truck Size and Weight, Route Designations - Length, Width and Weight Limitations
The purpose of Part 658 of the Code of Federal Regulations Title 23 is to identify a National Network (NN) of highways available to vehicles authorized by provisions of the Surface Transportation Assistance Act of 1982 (STAA) as amended, and to prescribe national policies that govern truck and over-the-road bus size and weight. The NN includes the Interstate System plus other qualifying Federal-aid Primary System Highways.
Current statutory language from the relevant passages of this part is included in its entirety in the chart that follows, along with the comments associated with sections impacted by a change in Federal truck size and weight limits. Additionally, to aid in the referencing of sections that would be impacted by a change in current Federal truck size and weight limits, the specific language impacted is underlined in the current statutory language.
previous | next